Posted on November 15, 2011 (updated: November 15, 2011)

Quebec gets ‘B-’ for drinking water protection

VANCOUVER — More than a decade after deadly gaps in drinking water management killed seven people in Walkerton, Ont., Quebec’s efforts to protect drinking water are getting weaker — despite the province’s recognition of water as a collective good, according to a new report from Ecojustice.

Waterproof 3, the environmental organization’s third drinking water report card, gives Quebec a ‘B-’ for lacking a comprehensive approach to protecting source water. Although the province is the only jurisdiction in Canada to recognize in law that water is a collective good and the government is duty-bound to protect its quality, Quebec still needs to take practical steps to meet this obligation.

“The province of Quebec is a leader in establishing the concept of water as a collective good and identifying its responsibility to maintain that for all Quebecers,” said Randy Christensen, Ecojustice staff lawyer and author of the report. “However, when it comes to source water protection, the important efforts of some municipalities are not consistent across the province.”

Waterproof 3 evaluates water policies, programs and legislation
across the country and assigns the provincial, territorial and federal
governments, a grade based on how well they’re protecting drinking water. Released every five years, the report also shows how each jurisdiction has performed over time on critical measures like treatment and testing requirements, drinking water quality standards, source water protection and transparency and accountability.

Quebec’s grade in Waterproof 3 is a drop from the ‘B+’ it received in 2006. The province continues to fall behind others like Ontario (A) and Nova Scotia (A-), which have been identified as leaders when it comes to drinking water protection thanks to strong treatment, testing and source water protection programs. In contrast, Alberta (C-) slipped in the rankings because of static treatment standards and poor source water protection efforts.

“The recommendations from the Walkerton Inquiry gave us a very clear framework for evaluating each jurisdiction’s efforts to provide safe drinking water,” Christensen said. “Those recommendations spell out exactly what it takes to properly monitor and protect drinking water, and yet some regional governments, as well as the federal government, still haven’t put them in place.”

The federal government is the only jurisdiction to fail outright
in Ecojustice’s report card for lagging on almost every aspect of water
protection for which it is responsible. Of greatest concern is the
government’s reluctance to create rigorous national drinking water
standards that protect peoples’ health and safety.

“The federal government has completely failed in its responsibilities
to ensure all Canadians have access to clean, safe water,” Christensen
said. “Despite the lessons learned from the tragedy in Walkerton, the
federal government has failed to pass drinking water legislation for
First Nations and lead the development of national water standards.”

Other key findings in Waterproof 3 include:

In some jurisdictions, improvements to water treatment, standards and testing have stalled and lost some of the momentum that came in the wake of the Walkerton tragedy

Full-fledged source water protection — a crucial first step in achieving safe drinking water systems — is lacking in industry-heavy areas where the risk of contamination is high

New technology has yet to translate into comprehensive, centralized and easily-accessible water advisories, particularly in remote rural areas

Climate change, unprotected source water and government cuts are emerging as new barriers to clean, safe drinking water systems

Ecojustice is the country’s leading charitable organization dedicated to using the law to defend Canadians’ right to a healthy environment.


Join our newsletter

Get updates on the most pressing environmental issues delivered straight to your inbox.

Join our online community

Follow us on social media