Defending the rights of Chemical Valley residents – Charter Challenge

Lockridge and Plain v Director, Ministry of the Environment et al.
Photo: © Garth Lenz
Program area – Healthy communities Status: Closed
Ecojustice’s position & impact
Meet the team
Get involved
Additional resources

Ecojustice lawyers represented Ada Lockridge and Ron Plain, two members of Aamjiwnaang First Nation, in their fight to ensure that the health of people living in one of Canada’s most polluted communities – Sarnia's Chemical Valley – is protected.

The approximately 800 residents of Aamjiwnaag live next to industrial facilities that account for approximately 40 per cent of Canada’s petrochemical industry. In 2011, the World Health Organization said that the people of Sarnia breathe some of the most polluted air in all of Canada.

In Lockridge and Plain v. Director, Ministry of the Environment et al., our clients asked the court to declare that an order issued by Ontario’s Ministry of the Environment that allows Suncor Energy Products to increase production at part of its Sarnia refinery violated their Charter rights. Our clients believe that the government’s failure to take into account the cumulative effects of pollution from all the industrial activity around their community violates Ada and Ron’s basic human rights under sections 7 and 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms – their rights to life, liberty and security of the person, and the right to equality.

In the years since the case was filed in 2011, the Ontario government has started to fix some of the problems that led Ada and Ron to take legal action.  That’s why, on our advice as their legal counsel, Ada and Ron have withdrawn the lawsuit.  To achieve our shared goal of reducing harmful pollution in Ontario communities, we’re now focusing our energy on ensuring the government makes good on its new initiatives — starting with its efforts in Chemical Valley.

We believe all Canadians have a right to breathe clean air and that governments have a responsibility to protect people and communities from unsafe levels of industrial pollution. The unjust distribution of the country’s pollution burden and, the impact for Aboriginal communities like Aamjiwnaang, has both health and human rights implications.

We are concerned by the Ontario government’s practice of assessing each source of air pollution individually to determine whether emissions fall within safe limits. Instead, Ron and Ada believe Ontario should assess cumulative impacts in pollution “hot spots” like Chemical Valley by evaluating overall air quality to determine whether a new source of pollution would raise emissions from all sources to an unsafe level.

What does this outcome mean?

Immediate, on-the-ground change is desperately needed in Chemical Valley and other pollution hot spots in Ontario.  That’s why we are putting down one tool and picking up another — changing course, at least for now, from litigating to working with Ada, Ron, and the Aamjiwnaang community to ensure that Ontario’s new initiatives lead to durable community solutions.

Working with Ada and Ron has deepened our commitment to advancing the recognition and protection of the basic human right to a healthy environment — including clean air, safe drinking water, and a stable climate.  When we first launched this case, few people in Canada had an understanding of what “environmental rights” were.  Five years later, a groundswell of public support has led more than 130 municipalities, representing a third of Canada’s population, to pass declarations in support environmental rights.

This is remarkable progress. Recognizing the right to a healthy environment is the natural next step in the progression of human rights law in Canada, and we look forward to seeing Canada’s governments take action on this front in the coming months and years.

Key developments

Press release

UPDATE: Lawsuit over air pollution in Chemical Valley discontinued

TORONTO — Ecojustice lawyer Kaitlyn Mitchell issued the following statement today about ongoing concerns with Ontario’s chronic failure ...

December 15, 2017

Press release

After eight and a half year delay, Ontario delivers disappointing cumulative effects policy

Ontario’s draft emissions policy would lead to ‘business as usual’ TORONTO — After an eight and a half year delay in reviewing how ...

November 9, 2017


Exposing Canada’s Toxic Secret

Is there a terrible cost to living in Canada's Chemical Valley? That's the question at the heart of a Global TV-led investigation — two y...

October 16, 2017


Ontario Residents in industrialized areas neglected by provincial air pollution laws

Province must consider the cumulative effects of pollution in toxic “hot-spots” For many years, Ecojustice scientists and lawyers hav...

November 1, 2016


Technical benzene standards: Why Ontario’s bait and switch approach puts people’s health at risk

After more than a decade of development and public consultation, Ontario’s health-based air quality standard for benzene is set to become ...

June 29, 2016


Changing course in Chemical Valley

Why we’re switching tactics in the fight to protect our clients from harmful pollution Five years ago, we helped our clients Ada Lockr...

April 26, 2016


Charge laid against Shell Canada for refinery spill in “Chemical Valley”

UPDATE 11/24/2015: Shell has pleaded guilty to the charges and has been ordered to pay $500,000, plus another $125,000 as a victim fine surc...

November 24, 2015

Press release

Lawsuit takes aim at College of Veterinarians’ refusal to investigate complaint

VANCOUVER — On behalf of their client, biologist Alexandra Morton, lawyers with Ecojustice Canada are suing the College of Veterinarians o...

January 5, 2015


Injustice continues in Sarnia’s Chemical Valley

I’ve known Ron Plain and Ada Lockridge, the two Aamjiwnaang First Nation members Ecojustice is representing in our Chemical Valley Charter...

November 5, 2014


Cross-examinations continue in Chemical Valley Charter Challenge

Today we continued cross-examinations in an important case to protect Ron Plain, Ada Lockridge, and their families, from industrial air poll...

November 4, 2014

Press release

Hydrogen sulphide detected on Aamjiwnaang First Nation Reserve

Sarnia — Shell Canada’s Corunna site chemical spill of hydrogen sulphide to the air on Friday, April 26 resulted in the same chemical be...

May 16, 2013


How a Sarnia duo defended their right to fight for clean air

Our case to protect a community from unsafe amounts of industrial pollution is back on track despite a year of legal wrangling from the gove...

March 22, 2013

Press release

Chemical Valley faces Canada’s Charter

TORONTO – Ecojustice is representing two members of Aamjiwnaang First Nation who allege that the cumulative effects of government-approved...

November 20, 2012

Press release

Lawsuit to protect Ont. families from industrial pollution in Chemical Valley being challenged by oil company

For immediate release TORONTO – Families in Sarnia, Ont., shouldn’t be threatened by unsafe amounts of industrial pollution, according t...

November 20, 2012

Press release

Report exposes Canada’s Chemical Valley

Ecojustice (formerly Sierra Legal) released an investigative report today that for the first time documents the staggering amount of air pol...

October 30, 2012

Press release

Chemical Valley residents demand new law for Ontario’s Pollution Hot Spots

Ecojustice (formerly Sierra Legal Defence Fund) filed a formal Application today with the Environmental Commissioner of Ontario calling on t...

October 30, 2012

Press release

Reproductive toxins discovered on Sarnia Reserve

A second air sample taken by the Aamjiwnaang Bucket Brigade contained some unpleasant results and further revelations about flaws in Canada'...

October 30, 2012

Press release

Aamjiwnaang Bucket Brigade discovers alarming levels of toxic chemicals in Sarnia

Bucket Brigade results reveal lack of public health standards for toxic air pollution in Canada SARNIA, ON – Bucket Brigade volunteers ...

October 30, 2012

Right to a Healthy Environment

December 15,2014

Join our newsletter

Get updates on the most pressing environmental issues delivered straight to your inbox.